It can be challenging to choose the right ice machine for your business when there are so many options. Depending on the industry, the type of machine and ice consistency needed will vary. With so many options for configurations and styles, understanding the options to choose from can help you select the best ice makers for your business. When purchasing an ice maker, you have several factors to consider because they all have different features. Today, we will be narrowing down your options and focussing on two leading ice machine brands: Scotsman vs Manitowoc. We’ll be diving into who they are, their products, ice type, cost, and more to ensure you’re able to make an informed decision.
Who is Scotsman?
Scotsman ice machines are among the best on the market. What sets Scotsman ice machines apart from competitors is their quality and quiet operation. Particularly they have remained one of the world’s largest manufacturers of ice machines and serve over 100 countries. In addition, their main selling point is their notoriety.
Who is Manitowoc?
Among the top names in the commercial ice-machine industry is Manitowoc. This brand is America’s #1 selling brand of ice machines and has been dominating the market since the 1960s. They are known for their energy-saving machines that are Energy Star certified.
Scotsman vs Manitowoc Ice Machine Products
Both companies produce various ice machines to meet the needs of different industries. The two companies offer similar products, so if you need an ice machine, you are likely to find that both companies can meet your business needs.
| Scotsman Products | Manitowoc Products |
| Modular | Modular |
| Remote Condensing (air and water-cooled) | Remote Condensing (air and water-cooled) |
| Undercounter | Undercounter |
| Countertop | Countertop |
| Hotel dispenser | Hotel dispenser |
| Specialty | Specialty |
| Ice Dispenser | Ice Beverage |
| Ice bins/storage | Storage & Accessories |
Scotsman vs Manitowoc Ice Type and Quality
There are several types of ice makers, but when it comes down to the types of ice they make there are 3 main types that both Scotsman and Manitowoc produce which are nugget, cubed, and flaked ice.
Manitowoc Ice Types
Manitowoc offers 4 versions of the traditional cubed ice. Moreover, this includes half-diced, diced, regular, and gourmet cubed ice. In addition, they offer nugget, flake, and crushed ice.
Manitowoc Cubed Ice Dimensions
| Type | Dimensions |
| Half Dice | 0.95 x 2.86 x 2.22 cm |
| Dice | 2.22 x 2.22 x 2.22 cm |
| Regular | 2.86 x 2.86 x 2.22 cm |
| Gourmet | 3.49 x 3.49 cm |
Scotsman Ice Types
Like Manitowoc, the company also offers cubed, nugget, and flaked ice. One key difference though is Scotsman refers to their cubed ice as cubers. Cubers come in 3 different types, big cube, prodigy cube, and prodigy plus eclipse.
Scotsman Cuber Ice Specifications
| Type | Description |
| Big Cube | 1¼” x 1¼” x 1¼” dimensions |
| Prodigy Plus | Variety of sizes |
| Prodigy Plus Eclipse | Produces almost 1800 pounds of ice each day |
Technology & Sustainability
Manitowoc
The age of technology is here, and yes, even ice machines are part of the movement. The commercial ice company is calling their Indigo NXT the next generation of ice machines. In addition, this machine provides next-level simplicity. It features a start-up wizard that showcases features, alerts, messages, status, and more.
- Touch Display
- Full status of ice machine at all times
Scotsman
In contrast, while not as technologically advanced as Manitowoc. Scotsman offers several Energy Star certified ice machines. The superior design reduces energy and water consumption making it environmentally friendly.
- 5 percent more efficient in water and energy usage than standard models.
Best Sellers
Commercial ice machines are a popular choice for many industries. Although there are many factors to consider when choosing the best machine for your business, reviews can make it easier. Take a look at where both rank.
In a review titled, “16 Best Commercial Ice Makers,” the number one spot went to Manitowoc’s UDF0140A NEO 26″ Air Cooled Undercounter Dice Cube Ice Machine. Why? Above all, the machine is an ideal solution for most businesses looking for a commercial ice machine. The device has a stainless steel body and produces regular ice cubes. Due to its stainless steel construction, it can easily be integrated into any environment to add a sleek look. Its compact design and ice quality is at the top of the game.
In the same review, Scotsman isn’t far behind Manitowoc. The number two spot is the Scotsman C0330SA-1 Prodigy Plus Ice Maker. Also in a sleek stainless steel design, this ice machine uses less energy than most other ice machines and requires low maintenance.
Cost
Ice machine costs can vary between $1,500-$10,000 per machine. Their pricing depends on the type and size of the machine and the type of ice. When it comes to both companies' best sellers which most commercial companies are looking to acquire, the Manitowoc will cost you $5,085 and $7,266 for Scotsman.
Warranty and Customer Support
Scotsman
Warranty for products begins on the date of installation, or 3 months after the shipment was made from Scotsman if no date was reported. Furthermore, their website offers a detailed breakdown of what’s included with the warranty depending on the model of the ice machine. For example, they offer both a 3-year and 5-year warranty.
The company provides a Toll-Free customer support number as well as a technical service email.
Manitowoc
On the other hand, Manitowoc's replacement parts are covered by their warranty for up to 90 days after installation. Additionally, after installation, compressors and evaporators are covered under warranty for up to one year.
Manitowoc provides a toll-free number for parts, service, warranty, and installation needs. In addition, they provide great customer support.
Scotsman vs Manitowoc: Pros and Cons
| Scotsman | Manitowoc | |
| Pros | Quiet Operation Simple Maintenance Quality Ice | Great customer support It has a substantial ice storage capacity Good Warranty |
| Cons | Sometimes Pricier than other brands Ice holding capacity may be lacking. | Quality Varies |
Conclusion
Both companies are reputable brands that offer similar features and solutions that can benefit various types of businesses.
- Manitowoc: If you’re looking for a highly regarded, innovative solution, and technologically advanced machine, Manitowoc will likely be best for you.
- Scotsman: However, if eco-friendliness is important to your line of business, this company's Energy Star certified machines are ideal for you.
Looking to Buy a Commercial Ice Machine?
Compare commercial ice machines completely free! With 360Connect, you can compare ice machines from top brands to find the one most suitable to your budget and business needs. Get a Quote
Related: